Canisteo’s written history begins with a mystery and runs through the river and the railroad.
Kanestio
Before European settlement, the valley held a settlement called Kanestio, sometimes called “Kanestio Castle.” Accounts disagree about who lived there: Steuben County historians describe a Delaware town of hewed log houses with stone chimneys, while a French account from about 1690 describes a community of European outlaws. It was the first place in what became Steuben County to be mentioned in writing. After two Dutch traders were killed in 1762, Sir William Johnson sent a force under Andrew Montour, and in 1764 the settlement was burned.
Settlers and Bennettsville
Settlers began arriving around 1789, making this one of the first settlements in what is now Steuben County. Trade at first ran down the Canisteo River toward Pennsylvania, since there was no direct route to Albany or New York City. The present village was first called Bennettsville; the original Canisteo, now the hamlet of Canisteo Center (Carson), lay southeast along the river.
The railroad era
The Erie Railroad opened in 1851 and brought factories and growth; the village was incorporated in 1873. With no room for a depot between the tracks and the river, the depot was built upriver on Depot Street, and a busy neighborhood with hotels and shops grew around it. Railroad Street–Greenwood Street became the village’s main street. An electric trolley, later the Hornell Traction Company, linked Canisteo with Hornell until 1926.
Keep exploring
The Kanestio Historical Society preserves Canisteo’s history. For Hornell’s side of the railroad story, see Hornell history.
Sources and official links
- Wikipedia: Canisteo (village), New York
- Wikipedia: Canisteo, New York
- Wikipedia: Hornell, New York
- Kanestio Historical Society
Hours, fees and seasonal openings change. Always check the official page before you go. Spot something out of date? Tell us at Partner with us.
Around the valley
- Canisteo events
- Hornell New York: our guide to the Maple City next door.
- Hornell events
- Hornell Arts calendar: events in Hornell and Canisteo.
- The Southern Tier on Live Finger Lakes: Hornell, Canisteo, Corning, Alfred and more.
- Southern Tier events
- Live Finger Lakes: the wider Finger Lakes.
